Chris Uggen's Blog: fatalities down for traffic, fire, and murder -- but not suicide

Saturday, January 09, 2010

fatalities down for traffic, fire, and murder -- but not suicide

When the Strib reported that Minnesota traffic deaths had fallen to a 65-year low, I checked the Department of Public Safety to see the long-term trend. They posted data from 1910 to present on traffic fatalities and from 1961 to present on vehicle miles traveled. The rate of deaths per mile traveled has fallen even more sharply than the rate per 100,000 population. As the figure shows below, both peak in the beautiful-but-deadly muscle car era of the late 1960s. Experts attribute the drop to safety features such as seat belts and airbags. Why, my own dad tells me that he started buckling up his seat belt when the legislature toughened the mandatory seat belt in 2009 -- he even stuck a post-it note on the steering wheel to remind him of the fine.Over the past three decades, the death rate has also fallen for homicide and fire in Minnesota. In contrast, the suicide rate has risen in recent years. In 2008, almost as many Minnesotans died from suicide as from fire, traffic, and homicide combined. The final numbers are not yet available for 2009, but I bet that the number of suicides now surpasses the combined sum of the other three categories. Moreover, at least some of the deaths classified as accidental fires, car crashes, and shootings may be victim-precipitated (e.g., one-car accidents, "suicide by cop").
Suicide rates rise with age, especially for white males, so the number of suicides is likely to rise in Minnesota as the population ages (the figures above are not age-adjusted). Nevertheless, the overall death rate across the four categories has fallen from about 38/100k in 1980 to about 23/100k in 2008. If these trends continue, I suspect that more social scientists will be turning their attention to suicide (and, presumably, Durkheim) in coming years.

3 Comments:

At 11:38 AM, Blogger Marissa said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 12:22 PM, Blogger Marissa said...

There's still so much stigma that prevents suicide from openly being addressed as a cause of death. There are so many euphemisms for a completed suicide that the reality of the situation is often masked by shame.

Imagine if instead of "non-combat related deaths" we heard on the news that there were 3 suicides by soldiers in Iraq or Afgahnistan. Or if instead of "died unexpectedly" it said committed suicide.

I thought about this after the triple homicide in Seward last week. The families who lost someone as a result of violence perpetrated by another individual are given public space to mourn, but those who lose someone as a result of self-inflicted violence are silenced by stigma.

What if right next to obituaries in the paper saying "died after a long and courageous battle with cancer" there were obituaries that said "died after a long and painful battle with major depression" (or bipolar disorder).

How can we reduce the stigma of suicide and mental illness? I believe that education is key to reducing suicide - education on how to access resources and education on the fact that many people successfully deal with mental health issues. I feel like you, Chris, are in a unique position to ensure that right next to the academic dishonesty discussion is the discussion of mental health.

I think there also needs to be some education on the fact that some psychological disorders have a typical on-set age coinciding with years traditionally spent in college (ever see The Soloist?). Not everyone knows or understands that it is a vulnerable time.


With any discussion of suicide, there needs to be some mention of a crisis hotline.
**If you are in a crisis and need help right away:
Call this toll-free number, available 24 hours a day, every day: 1-800-273-TALK (8255). You will reach the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline, a service available to anyone. You may call for yourself or for someone you care about. All calls are confidential.**

OR

Call 1.800.SUICIDE (1.800.784.2433) or click here to find hotlines for specific populations (grad students have their own line): http://www.hopeline.com/gethelpnow.html

 
At 11:12 AM, Blogger christopher uggen said...

Thanks, Marissa -- very helpful information, and timely too -- I'm walking through a syllabus tomorrow with a new group of 80 undergrads...

 

Post a Comment

<< Home